Briefing
On the morning of Monday, July 14, people walking around Alder Lake in the town of Harlow found dead fish along the shore. Lots of them. By noon the town had closed the beach, and by evening half the town had a theory.
Your job is to work out what most likely killed the fish. More importantly, you have to be able to show your work: which evidence you trusted, which you didn't, and why.
How to work the case
- Read the case files. There are 11 documents. Some are solid. Some aren't. A couple are somewhere in between.
- Log each source. Rate how credible it is and write down why. Think about who wrote it, how they got their information, who paid for it, and whether anything else backs it up.
- Pin up contradictions. When two sources disagree, write it down, and try to explain the disagreement.
- Write your verdict. Say what happened, what convinced you, and what you still don't know.
- Present. The Presentation tab pulls your notes into one page you can print or show the club.
published ≠ reliable
papers can have bad methods
correlation ≠ causation
lots of people repeating it ≠ true
convincing ≠ well supported
Your notes save automatically in this browser. Nothing gets sent anywhere.
Alder Lake (sketch, not to scale)
Click a folder to open it. Ones you've opened get a check mark.
Source Log
For every document: how much do you trust it, and why? "Mixed" is a real answer. Some sources get a few facts right and still jump to the wrong conclusion.
Contradictions Board
Pick two sources that disagree, describe the conflict, then try to explain it. (Different times? Different places? Someone exaggerating? Someone with something to gain?)